attorney photo

“I have been prosecuting serious injury and wrongful death cases against trucking companies, auto makers and tire manufacturers for more than 30 years. Our firm maintains this blog to share information and insight on transportation safety issues that continue to arise on our nation’s highways and roads.”

Source: The Ammons Law Firm

$50.65 Million Settlement for Our Clients in Sutherland Springs Church Shooting Case Against the U.S. Government

  • Settlement
  • Wrongful death
  • Church shooting

Key Facts

  • The court rendered a judgment of $230 million for all plaintiffs. The case later settled with the government for $144.5 million in total, and $50.65 million of that was allocated to The Ammons Law Firm’s clients.
  • This case marked the first time in U.S. history that the United States Government was held civilly liable after trial for a mass shooting.
  • The court found that Air Force failures to report Devin Kelley’s fingerprints and criminal history to the FBI proximately caused the plaintiffs’ harm.
  • The November 5, 2017 shooting at First Baptist Church in Sutherland Springs, Texas killed 26 people and wounded 22, according to the court’s findings.
  • Judge Xavier Rodriguez assigned 60% responsibility to the United States and 40% to Kelley in the July 6, 2021 liability ruling.

The case at a glance

CaseHolcombe et al. v. United States of America
ResultThe court rendered a $230 million judgment for all plaintiffs, finding the United States 60% responsible; the case later settled for $144.5 million, with $50.65 million allocated to our clients.
Case typeWrongful death and personal injury under the Federal Tort Claims Act
What happenedA prohibited purchaser obtained firearms after background checks failed to reveal his disqualifying conviction.
WhereFirst Baptist Church, Sutherland Springs, Texas
PlaintiffsSurvivors and relatives of those injured or killed
Court and cause numberU.S. District Court, Western District of Texas, San Antonio Division; 5:18-cv-00555-XR
Liability trialApril 7–20, 2021; bench trial before Judge Xavier Rodriguez
DecisionsLiability ruling: July 6, 2021; damages award reported February 7, 2022; settlement announced April 5, 2023
Ammons trial counselRob Ammons and April Strahan

Our clients were awarded $50.65 million in the litigation arising from the Sutherland Springs church shooting. The award followed separate trials on liability and damages before Judge Xavier Rodriguez. April Strahan and I were among the attorneys representing plaintiffs in the consolidated case against the United States. The case later settled for $144.5 million in total.

On November 5, 2017, families gathered at First Baptist Church in Sutherland Springs, Texas. A gunman entered the church and opened fire. Twenty-six people were killed and twenty-two were wounded. For the survivors and the families who lost loved ones, the question of responsibility extended beyond the man who pulled the trigger.

The gunman, Devin Kelley, had a criminal conviction that should have prevented him from purchasing firearms. The Air Force knew about that conviction. It also knew about his history of violence and threats. Yet the information needed to stop his purchases never reached the FBI.

What did the court decide in the Sutherland Springs case?

On July 6, 2021, Judge Xavier Rodriguez found the United States 60% responsible for the plaintiffs’ harm. He concluded that the Government negligently failed to collect and submit Kelley’s criminal history information and negligently supervised the personnel responsible for that work. Those failures increased the risk of harm and proximately caused the deaths and injuries.

The decision followed a bench trial held from April 7 through April 20, 2021. The judge heard the evidence and decided liability. A separate damages trial followed, leading to the awards reported in February 2022.

Why should the background checks have stopped Kelley’s purchases?

Kelley’s November 2012 court-martial conviction for assaulting his then-wife and stepson disqualified him from purchasing firearms. But when licensed dealers ran the required background checks for four purchases between December 2014 and October 2017, the system returned permission to proceed. His fingerprints and conviction information had not been submitted to the FBI.

A background check can only act on the information available to it. At trial, FBI representative Kimberly Del Greco explained that a disqualifying record in the National Instant Criminal Background Check System (NICS) Indices would produce an automatic denial. That testimony helped connect the missing records to the protection the background check system was supposed to provide.

What evidence showed that the Air Force failed to do its job?

The evidence showed repeated opportunities to report Kelley’s criminal history, during the investigation and after his conviction. The court found failures by both investigative personnel and confinement personnel. It also found that an Air Force supervisor certified that the fingerprints and final disposition had been sent to the FBI when they had not.

The physical file mattered. The checklist entries for the fingerprint card and final disposition report were blank. The court found that a proper supervisory review would have revealed the missing submissions and led to corrective action. Comparing what the electronic record claimed with what the underlying file actually contained helped explain how the failure continued.

How did we connect the reporting failures to the shooting?

Showing that records were missing was only part of the case. We also had to establish that the failures contributed to the harm. The Government argued that Kelley could have acquired guns elsewhere. The court examined his actual conduct and found that every firearm he possessed on the day of the shooting came from a licensed dealer.

The court rejected the idea that a possible alternative source established what Kelley probably would have done. It found that proper reporting would more likely than not have deterred him from carrying out the church shooting. The decision rested on the evidence about Kelley, his purchases, and his behavior, rather than speculation about other ways a person might obtain a gun.

Why did the court hold the Government responsible as well as the shooter?

The court found that the Air Force knew about Kelley’s violence and threats, including threats of a mass shooting. His criminal conduct did not erase the consequences of the Government’s own negligence. The judge concluded that both contributed to the harm and assigned responsibility to Kelley, Air Force personnel, and Air Force leadership.

Person or group Share of responsibility
Devin Patrick Kelley 40%
Air Force investigative agents and Security Forces personnel 20%
Air Force Office of Special Investigations Detachment 225 leadership 40%

The two Air Force allocations total 60%. The July 2021 ruling also held the United States jointly and severally liable for damages. The amount of those damages was addressed in the separate damages phase.

How much were our clients awarded?

Our clients were awarded $50.65 million. That is their portion of the damages awarded in the Sutherland Springs litigation. Texas Public Radio reported on February 7, 2022 that Judge Rodriguez awarded more than $230 million overall to victims and their families following the separate damages trial.

The liability trial established why the Government was responsible. The damages trial addressed the losses suffered by the survivors and the families of those killed. The $50.65 million figure identifies the award to the clients we represented, rather than the combined award to all plaintiffs in the case.

In April 2023, the Department of Justice reached an agreement to settle all claims for $144.5 million in total, which resolved the pending appeals.

What did this case require us to prove?

For the families, explaining what happened required tracing a chain of responsibilities that began years before the shooting. We had to examine the criminal records, the reporting process, and the supervisory checks, then connect those failures to the harm. The court’s findings established that the Government’s failures had consequences for the people inside that church.

Sources: Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, July 6, 2021, pp. 1–2, 25–27, 55–57, 65–69, and 90–99; Sutherland Springs liability trial transcript, April 7–20, 2021, appearances and pp. 605–612.

Additional source: Texas Public Radio, February 7, 2022, Victims, family from Sutherland Springs shooting awarded $230 million

Historical significance: Duke Center for Firearms Law, February 9, 2022, Government Faces Massive Civil Liability for Sutherland Springs Mass Shooting

Talk with us after the loss of a family member

Our attorneys can talk with you about what happened. The consultation is free.

Call (281) 801-5617
Categories

Why Choose Us?

Our Firm Will Fight for Your Right to Compensation
  • We Wrote the Book on Tire Defect Litigation

    Attorney Rob Ammons has not only handled some of the most complex tire defect cases but also wrote the book on how to properly litigate these types of cases.

  • Team Approach to Handling Each & Every Case

    We have the resources to take on even the most complex cases. On every case, we bring in industry experts and other professionals to advise on complex legal issues.

  • Billions in Verdicts and Settlements for Our Clients

    Our seasoned legal professionals have handled some of the largest personal injury claims nationwide and have a proven track record of record-setting verdicts and settlements.

Let Us Help You

Request Your FREE CONSULTATION Today!
Call
(281) 801-5617 or fill out the form below to contact our team.