The Role of the Jury in a Wrongful Death Trial

In a wrongful death trial, the jury determines the outcome of the case. Composed of individuals selected from the community, the jury’s job is to look at the evidence, determine who is at fault, and then determine the amount of money needed to fairly compensate the victim for their injuries and suffering. The jury is only permitted to consider the evidence presented during the trial. The judge’s job is to make sure only credible evidence is brought before the jury. For instance, if a trucking company tries to manufacturer driving logs to try and prove their driver was not tired at the time of the crash, the plaintiff’s attorney can object to the evidence. The judge would make the call on whether to allow the evidence into trial for the jury to consider.

The jury’s primary responsibilities include:

• Determining Liability: The jury evaluates whether the defendant’s actions or negligence caused the death of the deceased.
• Awarding Damages: If the jury finds the defendant liable, they determine the amount of compensation the plaintiff should receive, covering both:
  • Economic Losses: Financial damage such as lost income, medical bills, and funeral expenses.
  • Non-economic Losses: Intangible damage like mental anguish and loss of companionship.

A verdict in a Texas district court requires agreement from at least 10 of the 12 jurors, emphasizing the importance of a well-prepared and compelling case. By presenting clear and persuasive evidence, plaintiffs can help ensure the jury fully understands the scope of their loss and the justice they seek.

Presenting the Plaintiff’s Case: Meeting the Burden of Proof

In a wrongful death trial, the plaintiff must prove their case by meeting the legal standard of a “preponderance of the evidence.” This means the plaintiff must demonstrate that it is more likely than not that the defendant’s actions caused the death and that the family has suffered losses as a result.

For instance, when there is a dispute as to what happened in the accident, where the defendant is saying the person who was killed caused the accident, the plaintiff has the burden of proving that the defendant, in fact, caused the crash. This can be especially difficult when the defendant is the only person who survived the crash, as is often the case in truck accidents.

In situations such as this, it is important to do a full investigation before trial to make sure you have the evidence needed to overcome the defendant’s testimony of what happened in the crash.

Expert Testimony in Wrongful Death Trials

Expert witnesses are a cornerstone of wrongful death trials. They offer specialized knowledge to clarify liability and calculate damages. Their testimony is crucial in translating complex technical, scientific, or economic information into terms the jury can understand, ensuring the plaintiff’s case is compelling and comprehensible.

Expert witnesses support the plaintiff’s case in several key ways:

• Establishing Liability: Experts, such as forensic pathologists, analyze the cause of death and link it to the defendant’s actions or negligence.
• Quantifying Damages: Vocational experts may assess the deceased’s earning potential, while life care planners may estimate future costs for the family’s support and emotional recovery.

Different types of experts are often used to strengthen wrongful death claims:

• Forensic Pathologists: Clarify medical evidence about the cause of death.
• Accident Reconstruction Experts: Demonstrate how the incident occurred and the defendant’s role.
• Mental Health Experts: Highlight the emotional toll on surviving family members.

Through clear and credible testimony, expert witnesses provide the evidence needed to connect the defendant’s actions to the family’s loss, ensuring the jury fully understands the tragedy’s depth and impact. Their input often proves decisive in achieving a favorable outcome for the plaintiff.

Contact us online or call (281) 801-5617 for a no-cost consultation.